Susie Cakes Menu & Prices (Updated: December 2022)

Susie Cakes Menu & Prices
Source: susiecakes.com

SusieCakes is a beloved All-American bakery offering classic desserts like cupcakes, cakes, puddings, cookies, and pies. What really makes SusieCakes so different from the rest of the bakeries is the fact that all desserts are made entirely from scratch using simple and natural ingredients. Just like our grandmothers, SusieCakes’ pastry chefs don’t use any ready store-bought mixes or artificial preservatives, making it the perfect place for those looking for delicious, sentimental sweets and a friendly, old-fashioned neighborhood experience.

If you love cake and believe that cakes should not be reserved for special occasions only, a slice of cake from SusieCakes will immediately bring a bit of celebration to your ordinary day. Susie’s famous Southern Red Velvet cake or everyone’s favorite Old-Fashioned 6-Layer Chocolate Cake are just some of the delightful cakes you can get from SusieCakes. Customers can also enjoy cupcakes, pies, and cookies of all shapes, sizes, and flavors, baked with love and dedication.

Want to see more of Susie Cakes’ menu? We have it right here, along with updated prices.

Susie’s Signature Cupcakes | Miniature Cupcakes | Pies & Cheesecakes | Specialty Layer Cakes | Cookies & Bars | Gifts | Beverages | Game Day Sunday Specials

View Estimated Prices in Your State

Reset
FoodSize & Price

Susie's Signature Cupcakes

Baked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Cupcakes may feature seasonal / holiday decorations.

Luscious Lemon

$4.25

Chocolate Mint

$4.25

Peanut Butter

$4.25

Signature Cupcakes


Please specify the desired quantity of each flavor selected in the special instructions box below.
Dozen - $51.00

Strawberry

$4.25

Seasonal Cupcake


Many selections of seasonal flavors and decorations for the holidays.
$4.25

Flourless Chocolate Cupcake


Made without Gluten.
$4.75

Flourless Chocolate Signature Cupcakes

Dozen - $57.00

Chocolate Vanilla Cupcake

$4.25

Fluffy Coconut Cupcake

$4.25

Chocolate Chocolate Cupcake

$4.25

Red Velvet

$4.25

Vanilla with Pastel Vanilla Frosting

$4.25

Mocha Cupcake

$4.25

Miniature Cupcakes

Bite-sized cupcakes, topped with our signature frostings. Perfect for parties!

Chocolate

$2.75

Miniature Cupcakes

Dozen - $33.00

Flourless Chocolate Miniature Cupcakes

Dozen - $36.50

Vanilla Miniature Cupcake


Comes with pastel buttercream frosting.
$2.75

Flourless Chocolate


Made without Gluten.
$3.00

Red Velvet

$2.75

Pies & Cheesecakes

Seasonal Fruit Pie


Flaky crust filled with seasonal fruit filling. Selections vary monthly.
6" - $13.50
9" - $36.95

Seasonal Cream Pie


Flaky crust filled with seasonal cream filling. Selections vary monthly.
6" - $13.50
9" - $29.95

Banana Pudding & Vanilla Wafers


Smooth, creamy, hand-stirred pudding, topped with fresh whipped cream.
$7.85

Seasonal Cheesecake

$7.25

Vanilla Pudding

$7.25

Specialty Layer Cakes

Tropical Coconut Cake


Vanilla cake layered with pineapple accented coconut filling, topped with fluffy coconut buttercream and shredded coconut.
$44.00

Vanilla Celebration Cake


6 layers of vanilla cake baked with colorful sugar confetti and frosted with our signature retro-blue vanilla frosting.
$44.00

Carrot Cake


Moist and delicious! Layered with our unique "praline filling" and topped with traditional cream cheese frosting.
$44.00

Old-Fashioned 6-Layer Chocolate Cake


"Just like you remember!" Towering high, moist chocolate cake filled and covered in rich, chocolate buttercream frosting.
$44.00

Seasonal Layer Cake

9" - $66.00

Luscious Lemon


Moist layers of vanilla cake filled with deliciously smooth and tart lemon curd, topped with vanilla buttercream and sanding sugar.
$44.00

Classic Marble Cake


Vanilla and chocolate cake marbled together with chocolate chips, filled and frosted with vanilla and chocolate buttercreams.
$44.00

Layer Cake

Slice - $8.50

Susie's Famous Southern Red Velvet


Deep red, moist cake lightly flavored with cocoa, filled and topped with traditional cream cheese frosting. Our best seller!
$44.00

Cookies & Bars

Fruit Crumble Bar


Blueberry filling baked on a shortbread crust topped with crumble. *Made without dairy and eggs.
$4.25

Whoopie Pie


Susie's exclusive! 2 thick, chewy chocolate cookies sandwiched with vanilla buttercream.
$6.50

Chocolate Chip Cookie


Everyone's favorite treat! Baked with brown sugar, butter, and semi-sweet chocolate chips.
$3.50

Classic Chocolate Brownie


Moist, rich traditional treat baked with chocolate chips.
$4.25

7-Layer Bar


Baked with chocolate chips, coconut, and pecans on a graham cracker crust.
$4.25

Snickerdoodle


Soft sugar cookies, topped with cinnamon.
$3.50

Flourless Peanut Butter Cookie


Made without gluten. Soft and chewy peanut butter cookie made without flour.
$3.50

Frosted Sugar Cookie


Thin buttery and tender cookies with decorative royal icing.
$5.50

Sweetheart Sandwich Cookie


Two sugar cookies sandwiched with rich buttercream.
$4.15

Lemon Square


Zesty, light lemon curd on a buttery shortbread crust.
$4.25

Gifts

Sweetheart Box

$62.00

The Petite Party Tower of Treats


Tier 1: 4 assorted whoopie pies, brownies, and bars; Tier 2: 6 cupcakes.
$49.50

Thank You Box


One dozen of our most popular cupcakes (assorted chocolate, vanilla and red velvet) decorated with a sweet saying of thanks! Gift wrapped in red grosgrain ribbon.
$62.00

Little Birthday Box


Our signature retro-blue vanilla cupcake with a single candle in an individual gift box! Finished with red grosgrain ribbon.
$8.00

Big Birthday Box

$62.00

Baby Bash


Tier 1: 6 assorted mini cupcakes; Tier 2: 4 assorted chocolate chip and snickerdoodle cookies.
$35.00

Beverages

Organic Lowfat Milk

$2.25

Bottled Water

$2.25

Game Day Sunday Specials

Chiefs Football Frosted Sugar Cookie

$6.50

49ers Football Frosted Sugar Cookie

$6.50

Chiefs Red Velvet Cupcake

$5.25

49ers Vanilla Cupcake

$5.25